Harry Scull, Jr./Associated Press
It seemed like a logical decision at the time. It was a cold, windy day at Rich Stadium in suburban Buffalo in 1993, and the hometown Bills were behind, 35-3, in the second half of a first-round playoff game against the Houston Oilers. With the outcome seemingly no longer in question and the weather rather uninviting, many fans simply chose to go home.
The score was not the lone reason for pessimism. The Bills were playing without Jim Kelly, their franchise quarterback; linebacker Cornelius Bennett, the N.F.L.’s defensive player of the year; and running back Thurman Thomas, the offensive player of the year, who injured his hip early in the third quarter. And the Oilers had crushed Buffalo, 27-3, the week before.
“I almost never, ever, ever give up, but at that point, I kind of did give up,” said Barb Beebe, who was at the game and is the mother of Don Beebe, then a receiver for Buffalo.
But just as it looked as if all hope was lost, the Bills proceeded to mount the largest comeback in N.F.L. history, a victory that two decades later — Thursday will mark the game’s 20th anniversary — still resonates in western New York.
Some of the fans who left early did not realize until much later that the Bills came back to win. Others heard it unfold on the radio. The game did not sell out, so it was not televised locally. The Bills did not allow fans who left the game to re-enter the stadium. The only way for those who left to get back into the stadium was to climb over an imposing fence. Many did just that until late into the game, when the team began to allow fans with ticket stubs back in the stadium.
Frank Reich, who was filling in for Kelly, said that when the Bills were facing the seemingly insurmountable deficit, a teammate reminded him that when Reich was in college, he led Maryland back from 31 points down to beat Miami.
“I knew it could be done, but I don’t think anyone was thinking about winning the game at that point,” Reich said recently. “It was about being a professional and not getting embarrassed.”
The improbable comeback was propelled by two botched kicks, a shanked punt, a bobbled snap and a noncall by the officials. A short kickoff set up a 50-yard scoring drive by Buffalo that cut the lead to 35-10. Then Bills kicker Steve Christie recovered his own kickoff — Marv Levy, then Buffalo’s coach, still insists the play was a flub and not a planned onside kick.
Three plays later, Beebe caught a 38-yard touchdown pass on first down to make it 35-17. Replays show that he stepped out of bounds before making the catch. Barb Beebe, who insists her son never stepped out of bounds, said that was the point when she regained hope. Cris Dishman, who was a cornerback for Houston, still says the noncall cost the Oilers the game.
“Why didn’t someone think of instant replay sooner?” he said. “Then that greatest comeback never would have happened.”
Reich threw three touchdown passes in seven minutes against the N.F.L.’s third-best pass defense to cut the deficit to 35-31. He then threw another touchdown pass to Andre Reed for the third time to give Buffalo a 38-35 lead.
The Oilers soon had a chance to tie, but holder Greg Montgomery bobbled the snap to botch a 31-yard field-goal attempt. Warren Moon drove the Oilers to the Bills’ 9 in the waning moments of regulation, and Houston kicked a field goal with 12 seconds left to send the game to overtime.
The Oilers got the ball first, but Nate Odomes picked off Moon’s pass at Houston’s 37, leading to a Christie field goal that gave the Bills a 41-38 win.
The Bills poured onto the field in celebration, and the fans who stayed — or returned — hugged and kissed one another, cried tears of joy and sang “Shout,” the team’s theme song, for the seventh and final time in the game.
At the postgame news conference, Reich recited lyrics to a Christian song that he said inspired him before taking questions.
Dishman was more direct.
“It was the biggest choke in history,” he told reporters. “Everyone on the team, everyone in the organization choked today.”